Regretting You had the setup of something promising: two sisters, Morgan and Jenny, each married and all four close friends, a car-crash that kills Jenny and Morganâs husband, the revelation of an affair, and a new romance budding between Morgan and Jennyâs widower. The trailer made it look like rich emotional drama. What we got feels more soap-opera than cinematic romance.
The pacing holds up: the film moves through the tragedy, the betrayal, the shifting relationships without dragging. But chemistry is hit or miss. Morgan and Jonahâs connection â central to the story â rarely convinces. When youâre meant to be rooting for them, youâre left feeling simply like a spectator. The promising dynamic between Morganâs daughter Clara and Grant (or Miller, depending on cast) is sweeter, and there are moments of charm there, but those moments canât carry the whole film.
What dampens the experience is that the story doesnât really dig. The premise sets the stakes: guilt, grief, shifting loyalties, and fresh love. But it only treats those themes as ornaments. We observe Morganâs pain, we see the ease of the other life-switch-ups, we watch Claraâs budding romance â but we donât feel deeply what any of it truly means. The relationships donât develop enough to earn their emotional arcs. And when major revelations arrive, the impact is muted.
So yes: the film is fine. It has enough moments to keep you watching if youâre already seated. The cast does what they can. But for a movie that promised to pull you into complex human emotions, it falls short of memorable. If youâre looking for something light and passable, this will do. But if youâre hoping to carry something away â a film youâll think about later â youâll probably walk away wanting more.
